It’s been long enough now that most people have stopped bringing it up. The ones who still do ask a little differently than they used to, with a hopefulness in it, and you can hear the hopefulness, so you tell them you’re doing better. Sometimes that’s true. Sometimes you say it because the other answer takes twenty minutes and you’re standing in somebody’s kitchen holding a drink. Either way you’ve got a version ready now, and within that version there’s a count running: how long it’s been, and whether that’s too long.
In my clinical experience, that count does more damage than almost anything else people carry through grief. I’d like to offer a different measure.
What most people get wrong about grief
The common picture of grief is a set of stages and a timeline. You move through denial, anger and sadness, and somewhere around the one-year mark you’re supposed to arrive at acceptance. If you’re not there yet, something must be wrong.
Grief doesn’t work on a schedule. There’s no point on the calendar where it’s supposed to be over, and being further out than you expected isn’t evidence that something’s gone wrong with you. The question that helps isn’t how many months it’s been. It’s whether the grief has some motion to it.
Grief isn’t a problem to be solved. It’s work, and it takes the time it takes.
Everyone goes back to their lives
For the first few weeks there are people around. Food shows up. Your phone doesn’t stop. Somebody you hardly know says something to you in a parking lot that you think about for a week.
And you go back to work, usually sooner than you feel ready for, because the leave runs out. The first morning back is strange. The coffee machine is the same, your inbox is the same, somebody needs a decision by noon. People are careful with you for about a week. Then the carefulness stops. You’re a normal colleague again, which isn’t an unreasonable thing to expect of you, and you meet it. Meeting it every day costs something.
Then it thins out at home too, which it has to. People have their own lives and they go back to them. Most of us get very little practice at staying near someone who is still in process, and after a while people run out of things to offer, so they offer hope instead. You seem better. You’re doing so well. Time helps.
The pressure you’re feeling usually isn’t coming from the grief. It’s coming from the room around it. Mourning has always depended on other people being there for it: a witness, a ritual, some shared form that gives the loss a place to sit. When that thins out early, you’re left carrying something in private that was never built to be private. By six months, a lot of people are doing exactly that, and it’s exhausting.
Freud, Klein and the work of mourning
In 1917, Sigmund Freud wrote a short essay called “Mourning and Melancholia” that shapes how I think about loss. His central idea was that mourning is work: an active, painful, piece-by-piece process in which the mind goes back over every memory and expectation tied to the person, one at a time, and slowly lets reality in. It can’t be rushed, because it has to be done in detail.
Melanie Klein, a generation later, added something essential. She noticed that mourning isn’t only about letting go. It’s also about reinstating the person inside you: the slow process of finding a form of them you can keep, one that can live alongside the loss. And she was especially interested in what happens when the feelings run both ways at once. If you loved someone and were also furious with them, or needed them and couldn’t be near them, both of those have to come through the loss with you.
That takes longer. It’s also much harder to say, because the public version of mourning has less room in it for the angry part.
When there’s nowhere to put it
Grief that gets hurried doesn’t finish sooner. It sits and waits.
It comes back later, and not always as sadness. As irritation that’s out of proportion to whatever set it off. As a flatness that isn’t quite depression but isn’t quite living either. As anxiety with nothing attached to it, or a sudden inability to sit in a room where a particular song is on. Sometimes it turns up years later fastened to a much smaller loss, a pet or a move or somebody else’s bad news, and the size of what you feel makes no sense next to the size of what happened.
It can run on the calendar, too. You hit a bad stretch in February, heavy and short with people and no idea why, and then you look at the date. The body tends to get there before the thinking does.
None of it means something has gone wrong with you. A feeling that needed more room was sent the message there wasn’t any, so it waited.
Anger, numbness, and relief
The picture most of us grow up with is a sad one, and sadness is in there. So is a good deal else.
Anger. At the doctors, at whoever handled the arrangements badly, at the person who is gone (this is the one nobody warns you about), at yourself for still caring so much.
Numbness. It can go on for weeks and feel like evidence that you didn’t love enough. Long flat stretches where you feel close to nothing, and then ten minutes in the car that take everything you have.
Relief. After a long illness, after a hard marriage, after years of being the one who handled it. It tends to arrive with guilt attached, because it seems to say something unforgivable. It doesn’t. Relief after a long illness is a statement about the illness. Relief after a difficult relationship is a statement about the difficulty. Neither one is an indictment of the love.
There’s also what happens on a good day. You get most of the way through an ordinary Saturday before you notice you haven’t thought about them since morning, and something turns over in your chest. People read that as forgetting. It’s usually neither forgetting nor a sign you cared less, and noticing it doesn’t oblige you to correct it.
You can say the angry part here. And the relieved part.
Grieving something that’s still alive
Not every loss comes with a service and a week off work.
Estrangement is a loss. Dementia is a long one, where the person is in the room and also isn’t, and it arrives in pieces over years without a single day anyone can point to. Addiction. Divorce. A friendship that mattered enormously for ten years and then faded, with neither of you doing anything wrong.
And there’s grief for something that never showed up at all. People who grew up with a difficult parent sometimes find, well into adulthood, that they’re mourning two things: the parent, and the relationship they kept expecting would eventually start.
There are losses that are hard to talk about at all. A pregnancy. Somebody nobody knew you were close to. Having no public word for a loss doesn’t make it smaller. These are harder partly because nobody around you treats them as losses, so the support that comes automatically with other losses doesn’t come at all.
Whether it’s been too long
People ask me this, usually carefully, usually near the end of the hour.
Time isn’t the measure I’d use. Grief that’s moving can hurt as much as it did in the second month and still be moving: what sets it off changes, what you can say about it changes, how much of the day it takes up changes. Grief that’s stuck stays in the same position, month after month.
When it’s stuck, something is usually holding it there. Anger you can’t say because the person is gone and saying it feels like betrayal. Guilt about a decision made in a hallway at two in the morning. Something that never got said, or got said badly the last time you spoke. A relationship you can’t describe honestly to the people around you, because the honest description doesn’t match what they think it was.
There’s another measure people run privately, and it’s harder on them than the calendar. You compare. Your brother seems to be through it. A friend lost her mother the same year and was back to herself by spring. That isn’t information about you. It’s information about two different relationships and what each one held.
When faith was the thing holding it
For some people, a death also takes out the structure that was supposed to make death bearable. If your faith gave you a way to hold this, and it didn’t hold, you may be carrying two losses at once: the person, and the account of things that was supposed to steady you. That second loss can be hard to raise in your community, so it often stays unsaid. There’s more on that double loss in when you still believe and something still hurts.
Coming in with it
There’s no route here that runs from where you are to somewhere better on an agreed schedule. What there can be is an hour a week where nobody’s hoping you’ll be further along than you are. Where the anger and the relief and the flat parts come out in whatever order they arrive, and I’m not counting the months.
Most of what happens is slow and less dramatic than people expect. You tell me about it again, and it comes out a little differently than last time, and we notice the difference. Something you’d been reporting as a plain fact turns out, on the eighth telling, to have a lot of feeling in it. That’s Freud’s work of mourning and Klein’s reinstatement, happening in real time.
Some of it turns out to be less about the person than about what the loss rearranged: who you are in your family now, a role that landed on you in the first month and never got discussed. It’s open-ended. Some people stay a season. Some stay longer. It ends when it’s finished.
One small practice
The next time the count starts running in your head, set it aside and ask instead:
What’s one thing about them I haven’t said out loud to anyone?
It might be tender. It might be angry. It might be small and strange. You don’t have to say it to anyone yet. Just let yourself know it.
Grief isn’t a problem to fix
Grief that’s still with you isn’t a sign you’ve failed to move on. It’s a sign of how much there was to hold.
If you’re running the count again as you read this, you can put it down for a minute. You don’t need your thoughts organized first, or a clear account of what the person was to you. Whatever’s in there, including the parts you think reflect poorly on you, is welcome. Grief work is part of the depth-oriented individual therapy I offer in Newport Beach and Fullerton, and by telehealth from anywhere in California.
Request a free consultation →